1967:
Moody Blues - Days of Future Passed:
This album marked the
formal debut of the psychedelic-era
Moody Blues; though they'd made a
pair of singles featuring new (as of
1966) members Justin Hayward and
John Lodge, Days of Future Passed
was a lot bolder and more ambitious.
What surprises first-time listeners
— and delighted them at the time —
is the degree to which the group
shares the spotlight with the London
Festival Orchestra without
compromising their sound or getting
lost in the lush mix of sounds.
That's mostly because they came to
this album with the strongest, most
cohesive body of songs in their
history, having spent the previous
year working up a new stage act and
a new body of material (and working
the bugs out of it on-stage), the
best of which ended up here. Decca
Records had wanted a rock version of
Dvorak's "New World Symphony" to
showcase its enhanced stereo-sound
technology, but at the behest of the
band, producer Tony Clarke (with
engineer Derek Varnals aiding and
abetting) hijacked the project and
instead cut the group's new
repertory, with conductor/arranger
Peter Knight adding the orchestral
accompaniment and devising the
bridge sections between the songs
and the album's grandiose opening
and closing sections. The record
company didn't know what to do with
the resulting album, which was
neither classical nor pop, but
following its release in December of
1967, audiences found their way to
it as one of the first pieces of
heavily orchestrated, album-length
psychedelic rock to come out of
England in the wake of the Beatles'
Sgt. Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour
albums. What's more, it was
refreshingly original, rather than
an attempt to mimic the Beatles;
sandwiched among the playful
lyricism of "Another Morning" and
the mysticism of "The Sunset," songs
like "Tuesday Afternoon" and
"Twilight Time" (which remained in
their concert repertory for three
years) were pounding rockers within
the British psychedelic milieu, and
the harmony singing (another new
attribute for the group) made the
band's sound unique. With "Tuesday
Afternoon" and "Nights In White
Satin" to drive sales, Days of
Future Passed became one of the
defining documents of the blossoming
psychedelic era, and one of the most
enduringly popular albums of its
era. On CD, its history was fairly
spotty until 1997, when it was
remastered by Polygram; that edition
blows every prior CD release (apart
from Mobile Fidelity's
limited-edition disc) out of
contention, though this record is
likely due for another upgrade — and
probably a format jump, perhaps to
DVD-Audio — on or before its 40th
anniversary in 2007. (by Bruce Eder
)
1968:
Traffic - Traffic:
After dispensing with his services
in December 1967, the remaining
members of Traffic reinstated Dave
Mason in the group in the spring of
1968 as they struggled to write
enough material for their impending
second album. The result was a disc
evenly divided between Mason's
catchy folk-rock compositions and
Steve Winwood's compelling rock
jams. Mason's material was the most
appealing both initially and
eventually: the lead-off track, a
jaunty effort called "You Can All
Join In," became a European hit, and
"Feelin' Alright?" turned out to be
the only real standard to emerge
from the album after it started
earning cover versions from Joe
Cocker and others in the 1970s.
Winwood's efforts, with their
haunting keyboard-based melodies
augmented by Chris Wood's reed work
and Jim Capaldi's exotic rhythms,
work better as musical efforts than
lyrical ones. Primary lyricist
Capaldi's words tend to be
impressionistic reveries or vague
psychological reflections; the most
satisfying is the shaggy-dog story
"Forty Thousand Headmen," which
doesn't really make any sense as
anything other than a dream. But the
lyrics to Winwood/Capaldi
compositions take a back seat to the
playing and Winwood's soulful voice.
As Mason's simpler, more direct
performances alternate with the more
complex Winwood tunes, the album is
well-balanced. It's too bad that the
musicians were not able to maintain
that balance in person; for the
second time in two albums, Mason
found himself dismissed from the
group just as an LP to which he'd
made a major contribution hit the
stores. Only a few months after
that, the band itself split up, but
not before scoring their second
consecutive Top Ten ranking in the
U.K.; the album also reached the Top
20 in the U.S., breaking the
temporarily defunct group stateside.
(by William Ruhlmann )
1969:
The Beatles - Abbey Road:
The last Beatles album to be
recorded (although Let It Be was the
last to be released), Abbey Road was
a fitting swan song for the group,
echoing some of the faux-conceptual
forms of Sgt. Pepper, but featuring
stronger compositions and more
rock-oriented ensemble work. The
group was still pushing forward in
all facets of its art, whether
devising some of the greatest
harmonies to be heard on any rock
record (especially on "Because"),
constructing a medley of
songs/vignettes that covered much of
side two, adding subtle touches of
Moog synthesizer, or crafting
furious guitar-heavy rock ("The
End," "I Want You (She's So Heavy),"
"Come Together"). George Harrison
also blossomed into a major
songwriter, contributing the buoyant
"Here Comes the Sun" and the
supremely melodic ballad
"Something," the latter of which
became the first Harrison-penned
Beatles hit. Whether Abbey Road is
the Beatles' best work is debatable,
but it's certainly the most
immaculately produced (with the
possible exception of Sgt. Pepper)
and most tightly constructed.
1970: The Move - Shazam :
The single most accomplished album
to be recorded by any of the
Birmingham rock bands (which include
the Moody Blues), Shazam is sort of
Sgt. Pepper with an attitude, a
mixture of expansive progressive
rock worthy of the Beatles and
high-energy music honed by years of
playing loud on-stage. The rendition
of Tom Paxton's "The Last Thing on
My Mind" pushes these guys
simultaneously into Byrds and Jimi
Hendrix territory, while "Beautiful
Daughter" is one of the most
unabashedly pretty records of this
era, and "Cherry Blossom Clinic
Revisited" is defiantly strange. The
album only exists as an import from
Japan, paired up on one CD with the
earlier Flowers in the Rain album
(all songs in print domestically or
a better German version filled out
with five live tracks from London's
Marquee Club, off of the super-rare
Something Else EP).
1971:
Ramases - Space Hymns :
by Dave Thompson
Although Ramases' debut album is
best known today for featuring the
infant 10cc as accompanying
musicians (the 1990 Repertoire
reissue even flags their involvement
on the front cover), it is, in fact,
deserving of considerably more
attention than even that merits.
Insistent, percolating rhythms float
across a lightly funky soundscape,
building with an intensity that ebbs
and flows with every track and
begging comparison with some of the
other, darker folk devils that
danced around the fringes of the
early-'70s British underground.
Comus, Gravy Train, and Dr.
Strangely Strange all inhabit
similar musical caverns, even as
they strained toward new peaks of
uniqueness, and Ramases shares that
ambition — and occasionally even
surpasses it. The opening
"Lifechild" sets the scene, one of
two songs (the other is "Balloon,"
later in the set) that all but strap
you aboard the spacecraft blasting
off from Roger Dean's excellent
sleeve design. From there, the
journey does occasionally stray into
territory that 10cc would enlarge
upon — or that they had already
visited via their earlier Hotlegs
excursions: "Oh Mister" is certainly
the disinherited second cousin of
"Um Wah Um Who," while "And the
Whole World" could easily have
become one of those insidious little
ballads that Kevin Godley used to
sing so sweetly. Again, however, it
is misleading to emphasize such
connections — Space Hymns was
Ramases' show from start to finish,
a mass of musical eccentricities
that spend the entire album
colliding with one another, without
once disintegrating into chaos or
nonsense. A beautifully atmospheric
album, then, Space Hymns remains one
of the most musically and lyrically
intriguing releases of an age where
darkness and atmosphere genuinely
meant something to their exponents.
If Current 93 had been making
records in 1971, this would be one
of their greatest.
1972;
David Bowie - Ziggy Stardust:
Stephen Thomas Erlewine - Borrowing
heavily from Marc Bolan's glam rock
and the future shock of A Clockwork
Orange, David Bowie reached back to
the heavy rock of The Man Who Sold
the World for The Rise & Fall of
Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From
Mars. Constructed as a loose concept
album about an androgynous alien
rock star named Ziggy Stardust, the
story falls apart quickly, yet
Bowie's fractured, paranoid lyrics
are evocative of a decadent,
decaying future, and the music
echoes an apocalyptic, nuclear
dread. Fleshing out the off-kilter
metallic mix with fatter guitars,
genuine pop songs, string sections,
keyboards, and a cinematic flourish,
Ziggy Stardust is a glitzy array of
riffs, hooks, melodrama, and style
and the logical culmination of glam.
Mick Ronson plays with a maverick
flair that invigorates rockers like
"Suffragette City," "Moonage
Daydream," and "Hang Onto Yourself,"
while "Lady Stardust," "Five Years,"
and "Rock 'n' Roll Suicide" have a
grand sense of staged drama
previously unheard of in rock &
roll. And that self-conscious sense
of theater is part of the reason why
Ziggy Stardust sounds so foreign.
Bowie succeeds not in spite of his
pretensions but because of them, and
Ziggy Stardust — familiar in
structure, but alien in performance
— is the first time his vision and
execution met in such a grand,
sweeping fashion.
1973:
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon:
Stephen Thomas Erlewine
By condensing the sonic explorations
of Meddle to actual songs and adding
a lush, immaculate production to
their trippiest instrumental
sections, Pink Floyd inadvertently
designed their commercial
breakthrough with Dark Side of the
Moon. The primary revelation of Dark
Side of the Moon is what a little
focus does for the band. Roger
Waters wrote a series of songs about
mundane, everyday details which
aren't that impressive by
themselves, but when given the sonic
backdrop of Floyd's slow,
atmospheric soundscapes and
carefully placed sound effects, they
achieve an emotional resonance. But
what gives the album true power is
the subtly textured music, which
evolves from ponderous,
neo-psychedelic art rock to jazz
fusion and blues-rock before turning
back to psychedelia. It's dense with
detail, but leisurely paced,
creating its own dark, haunting
world. Pink Floyd may have better
albums than Dark Side of the Moon,
but no other record defines them
quite as well as this one.
1974:
Genesis - The lamb lies down on
Broadway: The group's
only double studio album was the
culmination of their early period,
featuring Peter Gabriel in a bravura
performance in the role of Rael, a
New York street hustler, in this
musical drama. The singing and
playing are all strong, and the
remastered edition from 1995 is the
first CD edition that sounds as good
as (or better than) the superb
original Atco pressing from 1975.
The piece's length makes it
something of an acquired taste, but
most serious fans regard this as the
best record the group ever cut.
1975:
Queen - Night at the Opera:
Stephen Thomas Erlewine - Queen were
straining at the boundaries of hard
rock and heavy metal on Sheer Heart
Attack, but they broke down all the
barricades on A Night at the Opera,
a self-consciously ridiculous and
overblown hard rock masterpiece.
Using the multi-layered guitars of
its predecessor as a foundation, A
Night at the Opera encompasses metal
("Death on Two Legs," "Sweet Lady"),
pop (the lovely, shimmering "You're
My Best Friend"), campy British
music hall ("Lazing on a Sunday
Afternoon," "Seaside Rendezvous"),
and mystical prog rock ("'39," "The
Prophet's Song"), eventually
bringing it all together on the
pseudo-operatic "Bohemian Rhapsody."
In short, it's a lot like Queen's
own version of Led Zeppelin IV, but
where Zep find dark menace in
bombast, Queen celebrate their own
pomposity. No one in the band takes
anything too seriously, otherwise
the arrangements wouldn't be as
ludicrously exaggerated as they are.
But the appeal — and the influence —
of A Night at the Opera is in its
detailed, meticulous productions.
It's prog rock with a sense of humor
as well as dynamics, and Queen never
bettered their approach anywhere
else.
1976:
Alan Parsons Project - Tales of Mystery and Imagination :
Tales of Mystery and Imagination is
an extremely mesmerizing aural
journey through some of Edgar Allan
Poe's most renowned works. With the
use of synthesizers, drums, guitar,
and even a glockenspiel, Parsons'
shivering effects make way for an
eerie excursion into Poe's
well-known classics. The
instrumental "Dream Within a Dream"
has Orson Welles narrating in front
of this wispy collaboration of
guitars and keyboards. The EMI
vocoder is used throughout "The
Raven" with the Westminster City
School Boys Choir mixed in to add a
distinct flair to its chamber-like
sound. Parsons' expertise surrounds
this album, from the slyness that
prevails in "(The System Of) Doctor
Tarr and Professor Feather" to the
bodeful thumping of the drums that
imitate a heartbeat on "The
Tell-Tale Heart." "The Fall of the
House of Usher" is a lengthy but
dazzling array of musicianship that
keeps the album's persona intact,
while enabling the listener to
submerge into its frightening
atmosphere. With vocalists Terry
Sylvester, John Miles, and Eric
Woolfson stretched across each
track, this variety of different
singing styles adds color and design
to the album's air. Without any
underlying theme to be pondered
upon, Alan Parsons instead paints a
vivid picture of one of the most
alluring literary figures in history
by musically reciting his most
famous works in expert fashion.
1977: Brian Eno - Before
and after Science: Before
and After Science is really a study
of "studio composition" whereby
recordings are created by
deconstruction and elimination:
tracks are recorded and assembled in
layers, then selectively subtracted
one after another, resulting in a
composition and sound quite unlike
that at the beginning of the
process. Despite the album's pop
format, the sound is unique and
strays far from the mainstream. Eno
also experiments with his lyrics,
choosing a sound-over-sense
approach. When mixed with the music,
these lyrics create a new sense or
meaning, or the feeling of meaning,
a concept inspired by abstract sound
poet Kurt Schwitters (epitomized on
the track "Kurt's Rejoinder," on
which you actually hear samples from
Schwitters' "Ursonate"). Before and
After Science opens with two bouncy,
upbeat cuts: "No One Receiving,"
featuring the offbeat rhythm machine
of Percy Jones and Phil Collins (Eno
regulars during this period), and
"Backwater." Jones' analog delay
bass dominates on the following
"Kurt's Rejoinder," and he and
Collins return on the mysterious
instrumental "Energy Fools the
Magician." The last five tracks (the
entire second side of the album
format) display a serenity unlike
anything in the pop music field.
These compositions take on an
occasional pastoral quality, pensive
and atmospheric. Cluster joins Eno
on the mood-evoking "By This River,"
but the album's apex is the final
cut, "Spider and I." With its misty
emotional intensity, the song seems
at once sad yet hopeful. The music
on Before and After Science at times
resembles Another Green World ("No
One Receiving") and Here Come the
Warm Jets ("King's Lead Hat") and
ranks alongside both as the most
essential Eno material.
1978: Jeff Wayne - War of
the Worlds: Paul
Collins and Bruce Eder
Released 40 years after Orson
Welles' infamous radio version of
the H.G. Wells tale, Jeff Wayne's
musical version of War of the Worlds
straddles old-style radio drama and
contemporary orchestrated narratives
by Rick Wakeman and David Bedford.
And while it lacks the sophisticated
arrangements of, say, Journey to the
Centre of the Earth, it does boast
an impressively odd cast — this may
be the only time that a member of
Thin Lizzy worked with Richard
Burton, and the presence of Julie
Covington and the Moody Blues'
Justin Hayward in very attractive
singing roles attest to its pop/rock
aspirations. It's Burton's sonorous
tones that sustain this work; his
frequent solo narrations are
eminently listenable, whereas
sections featuring dialogue with
other characters often come off as a
bit stilted. The music is competent
studio rock, and "Horsell Common and
the Heat Ray" does strike just the
right balance between Burton's
narration and an accompaniment built
around a buzzsaw guitar riff.
Overall, it's pleasant as a period
piece, and still a fine way to
introduce younger listeners to
Wells' classic tale. (And if you can
find it in a vinyl, it comes with a
nicely produced narrative booklet
with gloriously lurid illustrations
by Geoff Taylor.) The album was
actually appealing on too many
fronts for its own good in many ways
— the Justin Hayward-sung ballad
"Forever Autumn," extracted from a
much longer piece on the double-LP —
showed some signs of appealing to AM
radio listeners and climbed to the
Top 40 based on airplay alone, but
by the time Columbia Records in
America (missing this boat entirely)
got copies of the single into stores
so that people could actually buy
the record, the song had dropped
back down; in the meantime, the
record became a favorite of discos
and dance clubs in New York and
elsewhere, where its extended,
highly rhythmic, synthesizer-driven
sections delighted deejays and
audiences, and Columbia missed
another bet by not releasing an
instrumental-only assembly of those
long passages. (In New York, for
years after it went out of print on
vinyl, the album was sought after by
club deejays eager to spin it).
1979
- Pink Floyd - The Wall:
Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Roger Waters constructed The Wall, a
narcissistic, double-album rock
opera about an emotionally crippled
rock star who spits on an audience
member daring to cheer during an
acoustic song. Given its origins,
it's little wonder that The Wall
paints such an unsympathetic
portrait of the rock star, cleverly
named "Pink," who blames everyone —
particularly women — for his
neuroses. Such lyrical and thematic
shortcomings may have been
forgivable if the album had a killer
batch of songs, but Waters took his
operatic inclinations to heart,
constructing the album as a series
of fragments that are held together
by larger numbers like "Comfortably
Numb" and "Hey You." Generally, the
fully developed songs are among the
finest of Pink Floyd's later work,
but The Wall is primarily a triumph
of production: its seamless surface,
blending melodic fragments and sound
effects, makes the musical
shortcomings and questionable lyrics
easy to ignore. But if The Wall is
examined in depth, it falls apart,
since it doesn't offer enough great
songs to support its ambition, and
its self-serving message and shiny
production seem like relics of the
late-'70s Me Generation.
1980
- Peter Gabriel - Peter Gabriel 3:
Stephen Thomas Erlewine - Generally
regarded as Peter Gabriel's finest
record, his third eponymous album
finds him coming into his own,
crafting an album that's artier,
stronger, more song oriented than
before. Consider its ominous opener,
the controlled menace of "Intruder."
He's never found such a scary sound,
yet it's a sexy scare, one that is
undeniably alluring, and he keeps
this going throughout the record.
For an album so popular, it's
remarkably bleak, chilly, and dark —
even radio favorites like "I Don't
Remember" and "Games Without
Frontiers" are hardly cheerful,
spiked with paranoia and suspicion,
insulated in introspection. For the
first time, Gabriel has found the
sound to match his themes, plus the
songs to articulate his themes. Each
aspect of the album works, feeding
off each other, creating a
romantically gloomy, appealingly
arty masterpiece. It's the kind of
record where you remember the
details in the production as much as
the hooks or the songs, which isn't
to say that it's all surface — it's
just that the surface means as much
as the songs, since it articulates
the emotions as well as Gabriel's
cubist lyrics and impassioned voice.
He wound up having albums that sold
more, or generated bigger hits, but
this third Peter Gabriel album
remains his masterpiece.
1981
- Rush - Moving Pictures:
Greg Prato - Not only is
1981's Moving Pictures Rush's best
album, it is undeniably one of the
greatest hard rock albums of all
time. The new wave meets hard rock
approach of Permanent Waves is honed
to perfection — all seven of the
tracks are classics (four are still
featured regularly in concert and on
classic rock radio). While other
hard rock bands at the time
experimented unsuccessfully with
other musical styles, Rush were one
of the few to successfully cross
over. The whole entire first side is
perfect — their most renowned song,
"Tom Sawyer," kicks things off, and
is soon followed by the racing "Red
Barchetta," the instrumental "YYZ,"
and a song that examines the pros
and cons of stardom, "Limelight."
And while the second side isn't as
instantly striking as the first, it
is ultimately rewarding. The long
and winding "The Camera Eye" begins
with a synth-driven piece before
transforming into one of the band's
more straight-ahead epics, while
"Witch Hunt" and "Vital Signs"
remain two of the trio's more
underrated rock compositions. Rush
proved with Moving Pictures that
there was still uncharted territory
to explore within the hard rock
format, and were rewarded with their
most enduring and popular album.
1982
- Asia - Asia: This
marriage of four players with
impressive pedigrees proved to be
the success story of 1982 when
Asia's debut lodged itself at the
top of the U.S. album charts for two
months. The album spawned a massive
number four single in "Heat of the
Moment," a follow-up Top 20 hit in
the sweeping "Only Time Will Tell,"
and a handful of other tracks that
received heavy radio play despite
going against the grain of the new
wave styling of the day. Produced by
Mike Stone, Asia's strengths were
the powerful vocals of John Wetton,
the nimble, classically tinged
guitar work of Steve Howe, Geoffrey
Downes' majestic keyboard playing,
and anchoring the band, Carl
Palmer's propulsive drumming. The
lyrics are overwrought at moments,
but there's no denying the epic
grandeur of the music, which
provided some much-needed muscle to
radio at the time, and did so with
style.
1983
- Marillion - Script for a Jester's
Tear : John Franck
At the time, Marillion's remarkable,
full-fledged 1983 debut Script for a
Jester's Tear was considered an odd
bird: replete with Peter Gabriel
face paint and lengthy, technical
compositions, Marillion ushered in a
new generation of prog rock that
bound them forever to the heroics of
early day Genesis. Intricate,
complex, and theatrical almost to a
fault, Script for a Jester's Tear
remains the band's best and sets the
bar for their later work. Filled
with extraordinary songs that
remained staples in the band's live
gigs, the album begins with the
poignant title track, on which Fish
leads his band of merry men on a
brokenhearted tour de force that
culminates with the singer decrying
that "…the game is over." "He Knows
You Know,," a song sprinkled with
drug paranoia and guilt; as the song
veers to its chorus, Fish announces,
"Fast feed, crystal fever, swarming
through a fractured mind." If "The
Web" hints at a grain of
commercialism, "Garden Party" is a
joyous anthem that showcases
Marillion at the peak of its powers.
Bogged down by some hilariously
over-the-top British poetry,
"Chelsea Monday" may be one of the
album's lesser moments (if there are
any), but the magical "Forgotten
Sons" concludes the opus
magnificently. Luckily for Marillion
fans, EMI released a remastered
version of Script with two different
versions of "Market Square Heroes,"
"Three Boats Down from the Candy,"
"Grendel," Chelsea Monday," the demo
of "He Knows You Know," and an
alternate track titled "Charting the
Single." A vital piece for any
Marillion head and an essential work
for any self-respecting first- or
second-generation prog rock fan.
1984 - Roger Hodgson - In the
Eye of the Storm:
Vocalist/guitarist Roger Hodgson
must have really felt stifled toward
the end of his tenure in Supertramp
in the early '80s — despite
co-writing and singing many of the
band's biggest hits — because his
solo debut, 1984's In the Eye of the
Storm, is a remarkable work of
explosive creativity. Hodgson wrote,
sang, arranged, and produced In the
Eye of the Storm, but the real
kicker is the fact that he played
every instrument himself, with a few
exceptions such as drums and
fretless bass guitar on a few cuts.
As a result, In the Eye of the Storm
is easily the best synthesis of pop
and progressive rock since, well,
prime Supertramp. The spirit of
traditional progressive rock
experimentation is alive on this
album; five of the seven songs
exceed six minutes. The brilliant
leadoff track, "Had a Dream
(Sleeping With the Enemy)," is nine
minutes long. An edited single just
missed the Top 40, but every second
of the sound effects, driving piano,
tasteful guitar, and Hodgson's
aggressive singing of this cynical
song must be heard to be fully
appreciated. "In Jeopardy" has a
cha-cha, shuffle-like flavor and
Hodgson's monotone vocals provide a
faintly creepy effect. The gentle
ballad "Lovers in the Wind" is
sweetly arranged. "Give Me Love,
Give Me Life" is exuberantly
optimistic and hyperactively bouncy.
"I'm Not Afraid" fearlessly flows
back and forth between darker
sounding melodies and upbeat pop.
The creamy "Only Because of You" can
be favorably compared to the
floating instrumental passages on
Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon
and Wish You Were Here. Without
question, In the Eye of the Storm is
an exceptional piece of highly
listenable craftsmanship.
1985
- Marillion - Misplaced Childhood:
John Franck
After the album-tour-album cycle of
Script for a Jester's Tear, Fugazi,
and the subsequent Euro-only release
of Real to Reel, Marillion retreated
to Berlin's Hansa Ton Studios with
Rolling Stones producer Chris Kimsey
to work on their next opus. Armed
with a handful of lyrics born out of
a self-confessed acid trip, Fish
came up with the elaborate concept
for 1985's Misplaced Childhood.
Touching upon his early childhood
experiences and his inability to
deal with a slew of bad breakups
exacerbated by a never-ending series
of rock star-type "indulgences,"
Misplaced Childhood would prove to
be not only the band's most
accomplished release to date, but
also its most streamlined. Initial
record company skepticism over the
band's decision to forge ahead with
a '70s-style prog rock opus split
into two halves (sides one and two)
quickly evaporated as Marillion
delivered its two most commercial
singles ever: "Kayleigh" and
"Lavender." With its lush production
and punchy mix, the album went on to
become the band's greatest
commercial triumph, especially in
Europe where they would rise from
theater attraction to bona fide
stadium royalty. The subsequent U.S.
success of "Kayleigh" would also see
Marillion returning to the States
for a difficult tour as Rush's
support act. In 1999, EMI/Sanctuary
re-released a remastered version of
the album, featuring a bonus disc of
oddities including live fave
"Freaks," the previously unreleased
"Blue Angel," alternate takes of
"Kayleigh" and "Heart of Lothian,"
and Misplaced Childhood's actual
demos.
1986
- Peter Gabriel - So:
Stephen Thomas Erlewine - Peter
Gabriel introduced his fifth studio
album So with "Sledgehammer," an
Otis Redding-inspired soul-pop raver
that was easily his catchiest,
happiest single to date. Needless to
say, it was also his most
accessible, and, in that sense it
was a good introduction to So, the
catchiest, happiest record he ever
cut. "Sledgehammer" propelled the
record toward blockbuster status,
and Gabriel had enough songs with
single potential to keep it there.
There was "Big Time," another
colorful dance number; "Don't Give
Up," a moving duet with Kate Bush;
"Red Rain," a stately anthem popular
on album rock radio; and "In Your
Eyes," Gabriel's greatest love song
which achieved genuine classic
status after being featured in
Cameron Crowe's classic, Say
Anything. These all illustrated the
strengths of the album: Gabriel's
increased melodicism and ability to
blend African music, jangly pop, and
soul into his moody art rock. Apart
from these singles, plus the urgent
"That Voice Again," the rest of the
record is as quiet as the album
tracks of Security. The difference
is, the singles on that record were
part of the overall fabric; here,
the singles are the fabric, which
can make the album seem top-heavy (a
fault of many blockbuster albums,
particularly those of the mid-'80s).
Even so, those songs are so strong,
finding Gabriel in a newfound
confidence and accessibility, that
it's hard not to be won over by
them, even if So doesn't develop the
unity of its two predecessors.
1987
- Jethro Tull - Crest of a Knave:
Bruce Eder -
Ian Anderson and company seemed to
make a conscious effort to update
Jethro Tull's sound on this record.
And, to the amazement (and distress)
of many, it was voted the Grammy
Award for Best Hard Rock/Heavy Metal
Performance. Truth is, it isn't a
bad album, with an opening track
that qualifies as hard rock and
pretty much shouts its credentials
out in Martin Barre's screaming lead
guitar line, present throughout.
"Jump Start" and "Raising Steam"
also rock hard, and no one can
complain of too much on this record
being soft, apart from the acoustic
"The Waking Edge," along with
"Budapest" and "Said She Was a
Dancer," Anderson's two aging
rock-star's-eye-view accounts of
meeting women from around the world.
The antiwar song "Mountain Men" is
classic Tull-styled electric folk,
all screaming electric guitars at a
pretty high volume by its end.
Overall, this is a fairly successful
album and arguably their best since
1978, even if it does seem a little
insignificant in relation to, say,
Thick As a Brick. By this time Tull
was effectively a core trio of
Anderson, Barre, and bassist Dave
Pegg, augmented by whatever
musicians (drummers Gerry Conway and
Doane Perry, Fairport Convention
keyboard player Martin Allcock, and
violinist Ric Sanders) that they
needed to fill out their sound. The
result is a very lean-sounding group
and a record probably as deserving
of a Grammy as any other album of
its year — in the cosmic scheme, it
sort of made up for Tull's not
winning one for Thick As a Brick or
Aqualung, or for Dave Pegg's former
band Fairport Convention never
winning.
1988:
Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime:
Queensrÿche scored their
breakthrough success with the
ambitious concept album Operation:
Mindcrime, which tells the story of
a fortune hunter whose
disillusionment with Reagan-era
American society leads him to join a
shadowy plot to assassinate corrupt
leaders. For such a detailed story
line (there is also a tragic romance
thrown in), the band keeps its focus
remarkably well, and the music is
just as ambitious, featuring a
ten-minute track with orchestrations
by Michael Kamen. Those experiments
don't tend to work as well as the
tighter, more melodic prog metal
songs, which are frequently gems,
especially the singles "Eyes of a
Stranger" and "I Don't Believe in
Love." Granted, the lyrics and
political observations can sometimes
be too serious and intellectual for
their own good (few bands, metal or
otherwise, can make lines like
"There's no raison d'être" work).
But despite the occasional flaws,
it's surprising how well Operation:
Mindcrime does work, and it's a
testament to Queensrÿche's
creativity and talent that they can
pull off a project of this
magnitude.
1989
- Fates Warning - Perfect Symmetry:
This was the recording that
established Fates Warning as a
progressive band. Their metal
influences still dominate the
group's overall sound; however, Mark
Zonder's unique approach to drumming
adds another level of depth and
credibility to the music. His double
bass, odd-time introduction to "Part
of the Machine" is the session's
defining moment. "Through Different
Eyes" is a catchy song that provides
insight into the band's future
pop/metal direction. "Static Acts"
still stands as one of the most
aggressive songs the band ever
recorded. Ray Alder's aggressive
singing has a genuine quality which
allows him to legitimately convey
his anger and pain without sounding
clichéd. "A World Apart" is one of
the weaker songs here; however,
there is some impressive odd-metered
drumming from Zonder. "At Fates
Hands" has become one of the band's
classic songs, and for good reason.
The incorporation of the violin and
piano provide a refreshing change
from the overall metallic sound.
While Alder and Zonder prove here
that the band is capable of
achieving many different moods and
sounds, the instrumental section of
the song reveals that both Jim
Matheos and Frank Aresti are still
dependent on their metal guitar
style. The most powerful song in
terms of lyrics, singing and playing
is "Nothing Left to Say," which
stands as the band's high-water
mark. A historic recording in the
progressive metal genre.
1990
- Queensryche - Empire: One of
the most praised metal albums of the
late '80s, Operation: Mindcrime was
an extremely tough act to follow.
But while Empire isn't quite on a
par with that gem, it is certainly
one of the most absorbing headbanger
efforts of 1990. Highly conceptual
and anything but redundant, Empire
demonstrates beautifully just how
imaginative Queensrÿche can be. If
anyone has bridged the gap between
the bombast of Iron Maiden and the
artiness of Pink Floyd, it is
Queensrÿche. But as much as one may
be reminded of Floyd's The Wall on
pieces like "Anybody Listening?,"
"Silent Lucidity," and "Resistance,"
Empire leaves no doubt that
Queensrÿche has a rich personality
all its own.
1991
- Savatage - Streets A Rock Opera:
Streets picked up where Gutter
Ballet left off, taking Savatage's
interest in progressive metal into a
full-album concept. Based around a
short story written by
producer/songwriter Paul O' Neill,
Streets is a diverse collection of
songs about a lost soul trying to
find himself in the New York City
night. Although not based around
real life events in the life of the
band, it's obvious the group is
quite attached to the material,
turning out very emotional
performances. Unlike many rock
operas where the story suffers to
further the music or vice versa, the
band finds a nice compromise on
Streets and is able to convey
feelings of deep sorrow, elation,
anger, and beauty, sometimes even on
the same track. Opening with a
snippet from Mozart's Magic Flute,
the group quotes from a wide range
of influences. "A Little Too Far"
has a show tune quality to it, while
the beautiful "Heal My Soul" takes
its melody from an old Welsh
lullaby. Both songs feature lead
singer Jon Oliva alone with a piano.
Savatage, who before Gutter Ballet
had only written a handful of
ballads, turns in several brilliant
ones here, concluding with perhaps
the band's greatest song, the
dramatic and impassioned "Believe."
That's not to say that there are not
a fair share of rockers, as well. In
fact, "Strange Reality," "Ghost in
the Ruins," and "Jesus Saves" are
among the leanest and most intense
the band wrote, and Criss Oliva got
more interesting as a guitar player
with each successive album. While
many metal guitarists seem only
interested in technical displays,
Oliva turns out material here that
equals the heart-wrenching singing
of his brother. Considering the
intensity and beauty of the diverse
material here, this is a fine place
to start learning about this band.
1992
- Dream Theatre - Images and Words:
Dream Theater's first album with new
vocalist James LaBrie is an
excellent mix of progressive metal
stylings with heartfelt vocals and
thought-provoking lyrics. Guitarist
John Petrucci, bassist John Myung,
and drummer Mike Portnoy, all of
whom trained at Berklee, show
impressive ability on their
respective instruments. Kevin
Moore's keyboards weave strongly
through the intricately constructed
songs, while operatically trained
LaBrie shows an impressive range
with his tenor. Standout tracks
include the complex "Metropolis, Pt.
1," the Shakespeare-influenced "Pull
Me Under" (also released as a single
and video), the dramatic "Take the
Time," and the 11-minute, thoughtful
"Learning to Live." Dream Theater's
musicianship and songwriting are a
cut above the norm; this is a very
good disc.
1993 - Tool - Undertow : Just as
grunge was reaching its boiling
point and radio-friendly punk-pop
loomed on the horizon, Tool released
Undertow, which firmly reinforced
metal's prominence as a musical
style — but, for once, it had
something worthwhile to say. At the
forefront of Tool's commercial
explosion were striking, haunting
visuals that complemented the
album's nihilistic yet wistful mood.
Drawing equal inspiration from Black
Sabbath, alternative theories of
science, and Eastern religions,
Tool's abrasive sonic assault begins
from the opening notes and continues
through the final moments of the
last composition, an open mockery of
organized religion and its
incapacity for original thought.
With its technical brilliance,
musical complexities, and aggressive
overtones, Undertow not only paved
the way for several bands to break
through to the mainstream adolescent
mall-rage demographic, it also
proved that metal could be
simultaneously intelligent,
emotional, and brutal.
1994
- Spock's Beard - The Light: The
Light is the debut album from
Spock's Beard, the Culver City, CA
neo-prog rock band whose sprawling
exercises in technical proficiency
and suite-like compositions made
them an underground legend almost
immediately. One has to understand
that The Light is nothing at all
akin to anything being done in the
mid-'90s. Yes hadn't yet made their
full comeback, and the memories of
Genesis with Peter Gabriel faded
ever more pervasively form view with
each subsequent Phil Collins solo
release. Here are four sprawling,
knotty, syncopated tunes, two of
them, the title track and "The
Water," are multiple-part suites
that encompass no less than 48
minutes of the album's 67 minutes.
In addition, this album was
self-financed. (What "responsible"
multi-national recording
conglomerate during Nirvana-mania
would give them a record deal after
all?). There are wonderfully
referenced elements here in these
massive and yes, overblown
constructions — but that's what
prog's delight is — it's overblown
and confoundingly complex. There's
the great King Crimson "21st Century
Schizoid Man" reference in "One
Man," and the
flamenco-cum-near-gothic metal of
the "Return of the Catfish Man,"
near the end of The Light. The
layered keyboards and backing chorus
in "Go the Way You Go" reminds one
of Yes at their knottiest, before
slipping expertly into an altered
universe dynamically and becoming a
poetic and romantic elegy. And "The
Water"'s labyrinthine, apocalyptic,
maze-like compositional journey that
may not sound like punk, but
certainly reflects many of its
sentiments, is an anomaly in any
kind of music that espouses this
M.O. The dodgy (but not substandard)
recording makes it sound like
classic- '70s vintage, and the music
is out of time and space. Fans of
this genre have long regarded it as
a classic.
1995
- Flower Kings - Back in the world
of Adventures: Roine Stolt's voice
is strong, full, passionate, and
delightfully accented. The Flower
Kings' lyrics are heady, compelling,
and hook-city. The guitar work is
extremely melodic and rates right up
there with anything Brian May or
David Gilmour has offered. Stolt is
expertly meshed in this band with
brother Michael on bass and voice.
Tomas Bodin excels on Hammond organ,
Mellotron, piano, and flute. Hasse
Bruniusson is percussion alongside
Jamie Salazar on drum kit. Ulf
Wallander guests on sax. Ten songs
offer five instrumentals and five
with great vocals mingled with
extended instrumental bridges and a
variety of sonic excursions. Each
piece is a rocking, swirling matrix,
of multifaceted sound-gems
glistening in an endless cascade of
wonder. "Big Wheel" and "World of
Adventures" baptized me in
concentric waves of synapse firings
and flooded my heart with
gossamer-winged butterflies. Take
the best of Crack the Sky, Pink
Floyd, early Genesis, and the
pop-rock, slickcool of Queen and
Prince's 1999, mix it all together
in the cauldron of Stolt's vision of
world peace and out comes a fresh
batch of magic.
1996
- Tool - Aenima: For their third
release, Tool explore the
progressive rock territory
previously forged by such bands as
King Crimson. However, Tool are
conceptually innovative with every
minute detail of their art, which
sets them apart from most bands.
Make no mistake, this isn't your
father's rock record. Sonically, the
band has never sounded tighter. Long
exploratory passages are unleashed
with amazing precision, detail, and
clarity, which only complements the
aggressive, abrasive shorter pieces
on the album. There is no compromise
from any member of the band, with
each of them discovering the
dynamics of his respective
instrument and pushing the physical
capabilities to the limit. Topics
such as the philosophies of Bill
Hicks (eloquently eulogized in the
packaging), evolution and genetics,
and false martyrdom will fly over
the heads of casual listeners. But
those listening closely will
discover a special treat: a catalyst
encouraging them to discover a world
around them to which they otherwise
might have been blind. If these
aren't good enough reasons to listen
to Ænima, then just trust the simple
fact that Tool deliver the hard rock
goods every time the band chooses to
release something.
1997
- Radiohead - OK Computer :
Using the textured soundscapes of
The Bends as a launching pad,
Radiohead delivered another
startlingly accomplished set of
modern guitar rock with OK Computer.
The anthemic guitar heroics present
on Pablo Honey and even The Bends
are nowhere to be heard here.
Radiohead have stripped away many of
the obvious elements of guitar rock,
creating music that is subtle and
textured yet still has the feeling
of rock & roll. Even at its most
adventurous — such as the complex,
multi-segmented "Paranoid Android" —
the band is tight, melodic, and
muscular, and Thom Yorke's voice
effortlessly shifts from a sweet
falsetto to vicious snarls. It's a
thoroughly astonishing demonstration
of musical virtuosity and becomes
even more impressive with repeated
listens, which reveal subtleties
like electronica rhythms, eerie
keyboards, odd time signatures, and
complex syncopations. Yet all of
this would simply be showmanship if
the songs weren't strong in
themselves, and OK Computer is
filled with moody masterpieces, from
the shimmering "Subterranean
Homesick Alien" and the sighing
"Karma Police" to the gothic crawl
of "Exit Music (For a Film)." OK
Computer is the album that
establishes Radiohead as one of the
most inventive and rewarding guitar
rock bands of the '90s.
1998
- IQ - Subterranea: Released in
September 1997, Subterranea was
quickly hailed by most progressive
rock critics as a masterpiece and
became one of the very few "classic"
albums this style brought forth in
1990s. The two-CD, 103-minute
concept album is indeed IQ's
strongest effort and would even
eclipse The Wake, if it weren't for
the historical significance of the
1985 LP. An obscure story of
subterranean beings, life-and-death
chase, and initiatory quest packed
with metaphorical implications,
Subterranea, as a concept, is
typical Peter Nicholls; all lyrics
remain vague, only suggesting
emotions and bits of plot, but to
phenomenal results. The easy
comparison would be Genesis' The
Lamb Lies Down on Broadway and, yes,
there is something of that in here,
but the meaning of this album is
even more cryptic. The music is
rooted in IQ's neo-prog past: rather
simple songs, driven by Martin
Orford's keyboards and Peter
Nicholls' theatrical and
emotion-packed vocals, dressed in
progressive rock grandeur without
the flashy chops, and — most of all
— very strong melodies. This monster
of an album takes some time to get
used to. After the first listen, one
is left puzzled and uncertain, but
once some of the melodies have had a
chance to implement themselves in
one's brain, Subterranea quickly
becomes a "desert island" disc.
Highlights include the rocking title
track and "Tunnel Vision," the
pompous "Failsafe," the
heartbreaking ballad "Capricorn"
(embellished by the saxophone of
guest Tony Wright), and the short
"State of Mind" and "Laid Low." The
first of these two ends the first
disc, while the second opens disc
two, thereby presenting the
"positive" and "negative" sides of
the same melody — a very clever way
to link the two parts of the album
as two "acts." The only weak track
of the set is the 20-minute epic
"The Narrow Margin." Coming at the
end, it is simply too hard to
digest, and it seems to lose its
cohesion somewhere in the middle.
Nevertheless, Subterranea is IQ's
biggest musical accomplishment and
will get under the skin of any prog
fan. A live version of the album was
released in 2000 under the title
Subterranea: The Concert.
1999
- Opeth - Still Life: Having
taken their oppressive black metal
symphonies to their furious zenith
with their third effort, My Arms,
Your Hearse, Sweden's Opeth began
deconstructing their sound on 1999's
brilliant Still Life. A logical next
step in their evolution, the album
finds the band re-examining their
unlikely fusion of progressive rock
and black metal to highlight the
former while staying in touch with
the latter. The result is a
formidable splicing of harsh, often
jagged guitar riffs with graceful
melodies, and the increasing use of
Mikael Akerfeldt's "clean" vocals
(alternated with his ever-present
death growl). This tactic only
serves to spotlight the quality of
Akerfeldt's lyrics (a rarity in
extreme metal circles) and, in the
tradition of prior efforts, Still
Life is a full-fledged concept
album, which, without going into
unnecessary details, centers around
a tale of unrequited love for a
character called Melinda (a discreet
reference to Mercyful Fate's
early-'80s classic Melissa,
perhaps?). Also new to the mix are a
wealth of more dynamic, almost
groove-oriented riffs (see
"Godhead's Lament" and "Serenity
Painted Death") which break away
from the Wall of Sound overtures of
the past. On the other hand,
outstanding, multi-faceted epics
like "The Moor," "Moonlapse
Vertigo," and "White Cluster" carry
on in the proud Opeth tradition. The
all-acoustic "Benighted" is the
album's only one-dimensional track
(and a beauty it is, too), while the
awesome "Face of Melinda" represents
a new career high with its quietly
building atmosphere and powerful
finale. Ultimately, this is another
star turn for the group, and the
fact that they somehow managed to
outdo themselves with their next
work, Blackwater Park, is a
testament to Opeth's greatness.
2000
- Radiohead - Kid A : Instead of
simply adding club beats or sonic
collage techniques, Radiohead strive
to incorporate the unsettling
"intelligent techno" sound of
Autechre and Aphex Twin,
characterized by its skittering
beats and stylishly dark sonic
surfaces, for Kid A. To their
immense credit, Radiohead don't
sound like carpetbaggers, because
they share the same post-postmodern
vantage point as their inspirations.
As a result, Kid A is easily the
most successful electronica album
from a rock band — it doesn't even
sound like a rock band, even if it
does sound like Radiohead. So, Kid A
is an unqualified success? Well, not
quite. Despite its admirable
ambition, Kid A is never as
visionary or stunning as OK
Computer, nor does it really repay
the time it demands. OK Computer
required many plays before revealing
the intricacies of its densely
layered mix; here, multiple plays
are necessary to discern the music's
form, to get a handle on quiet,
drifting, minimally arranged songs
with no hooks. Of course, the
natural reaction of any serious
record geek is that if the music
demands so much work, it must be
worth it — and at times, that
supposition is true. But Kid A's
challenge doesn't always live up to
its end of the bargain. It's
self-consciously alienating and
difficult, and while that can be
intriguing, it seems deeper than it
actually is. Repeated plays
dissipate the mystique and reveal a
number of rather drab songs
(primarily during the second half),
where there isn't enough under the
surface to make Radiohead's
relentless experimentation
satisfying. But mixed results are
still results, and about half of the
songs positively shimmer with
genius.
2001
- Therion - Secret of the Runes:
Secret of the Runes is a concept
album whose concept is centuries
old. Norse mythology is said to have
nine different worlds or planes, and
each world gets a track devoted to
it. With the lyrics that are sung in
several different languages, it's
hard to keep up unless you're a UN
translator in your spare time.
However, the operatic overtures
transcend verbal communication, as
every song swells and recedes with
majestic aplomb, taking the listener
on a ride that sounds more like a
very loud opera instead of anything
with a metallic base. Christofer
Johnsson's gothic flair for the
dramatic has never been more
pronounced than on this, the band's
tenth album, and the life he
breathes into underground metal will
make up for the breath it takes away
from its listeners. Metallica's
forays with a symphonic orchestra
sound like being stuck between two
radio stations compared to the
seamless integration of metallic
trappings and Wagnerian soundscapes.
Therion continues to be one of the
most painstakingly original acts,
and even those who think the band
strays too far from their roots with
each subsequent album have to marvel
at the musicianship and imagination
Therion displays on Secret of the
Runes.
2002
- Porcupine Tree - In Absentia:
Continuing in the growing commercial
vein of their previous releases,
Porcupine Tree's In Absentia may be
the most accessible release to ever
spew forth from the group. Rolling
electronic percussion blends with
simple and solid live drumming to
provide an understated backbeat as
perennial Tree leader Steven Wilson
pastes his complicated pop over the
proceedings. Wilson's ability to
bury his layered vocals in mountains
of spacy electric guitar without
drowning out his fragile lyrics is
still a valued feature of the music,
and the rare moments of clarity that
his vocals display are breathtaking
in their power. A reliance on a
somewhat gothic heavy metal sound
makes for some bizarre moments,
especially when held up against his
gentler material. The best example
of this is the chugging "Wedding
Nails," which recalls Dream Theater
in its grandiose scope without
utilizing the same sort of technical
wizardry. But Wilson manages to
bridge the gap between the various
genres he utilizes, creating an
environment where his haunting
melodies could take a drastic turn
at any minute. Porcupine Tree also
continue their Radiohead
fascination, although the influence
is much less direct than on their
last few efforts. Instead, it comes
through at odd moments, like the
moments of sparse instrumentation on
the otherwise lush "Heartattack in a
Layby." Sonically gorgeous and
deceivingly complex, In Absentia has
the most immediate appeal of
anything Wilson has released under
this moniker up to this point. By
keeping the songs at manageable
lengths and avoiding the avant-garde
electronica flourishes of the band's
early days, Porcupine Tree grow into
a fully realized pop group without
cutting any of the elements that
also makes them an important force
in the neo-prog movement.
2003
- Rush in Rio: Set for
production as a live DVD from the
Vapour Trails tour, the audio from
Rush in Rio clearly stands as a
startling historical and musical
document. The live mix is simply
superb and reveals the show as it
happened, without overdubs or DAT
splices. The band played in front of
their second-largest crowd ever,
40,000 people on the final night of
the tour. (The largest was
60,000-plus the night before in São
Paulo in the rain.) Covering three
CDs, this is one of those documents
that can make a punter wonder why he
ever doubted the glory, majesty, and
heavy, overblown, pretentious rock
power of Rush. Opening with
thunderous crowd noise, "Tom Sawyer"
— with complete audience
participation from the git — it is
somehow awe-inspiring to hear 40,000
people singing the song with Geddy
Lee. These people are so crazy; they
aren't left out of the mix because
they couldn't be! But it works.
There was no soundcheck that night
due to production delays in the
arena. This is the sound of a band
going for it in spite of everything
and on the wing — and the sound,
very live, very real, extremely
dynamic — and not only do they pull
it off; they issue their best live
outing ever. Seeing Rush live can be
an experience, but only those people
in Rio saw them like this: far from
complacent veteran rock stars, they
musically push their own envelopes
to the breaking point and goad each
other onto ever greater intensity.
Lee's bass playing has never been
this ferocious, so aggressive and
driving — on a live album anyway.
Neil Peart pushes the entire band
with his polyrhythmic assault and
overdriven flourishes and fills;
knowing this is the last date, he
gives it all up in every single
track. And Alex Lifeson, ever the
band player, is, on this night
anyway, simply the greatest arena
rock guitarist in the world. The
program ranges over the band's
entire recorded output. The majority
of the material comes from Farewell
to Kings and after, though "Working
Man," "2112," and a medley of
"By-Tor and the Snow Dog" and
"Cygnus X-1" are present here.
Versions of "Roll the Bones," "The
Big Money," "One Little Victory,"
"Ghost Rider," "Red Sector A," and
"La Villa Strangiato" are given
something like their definitive
reads. Again, on well-known tracks
like "Closer to the Heart," "Free
Will," and "Spirit of Radio," the
crowd participation would normally
be off-putting. In this context,
however, it is an asset. One can
hear how this adulation and frenzy
literally feeds the band, forcing
the issue and making these
breathtaking performances. To round
out the encores on disc three Rush
has included "board bootlegs" of
"Between Sun & Moon" and "Vital
Signs" that are more than worthy
performances. They were taken from
shows in Phoenix and Quebec. For
those for whom Rush is a secret and
guilty pleasure, it's time to
indulge it openly by playing this
for friends who erroneously insist
that Sonic Youth or Strokes concert
bootlegs are the epitome of
"big-label live rock." For the
faithful, you'll know. This one is
bloody great.
2004
- Touch - Touch : Touch's only
album briefly enjoyed legendary
status during its recording and
again shortly after its release, but
all too rapidly entered the realm of
the well-kept secret. It may or may
not be the very first progressive
rock album, but what is indisputable
is that few bands engineered a more
satisfying collision of rock, jazz,
psychedelia, and classical music
during the genre's heyday. Much of
the album's effectiveness stems from
the soaring imagination of the
band's leader, keyboard player, and
principal composer Don Gallucci,
incredibly just 19 years old.
Throughout, he plays only piano,
clavinet, and what sounds like a
cheesy old theater organ — no
Mellotron, no synths — yet he does
so with a virtuosity tempered by the
kind of restraint that would become
all too rare among bands like ELP,
Yes, and other behemoths of the prog
era. Opener "We Feel Fine"
demonstrates that this is a band
that can rock, too — an impression
confirmed by the band's single "Miss
Teach." But it's "Friendly Birds"
that confirms that Touch could do a
lot more than kick ass. Essentially
a trio for piano, guitar, and bass —
with a brief vocal introduction —
its dynamic range alone makes it
remarkable. Over the course of just
four minutes, it swoops and soars as
piano and guitar trade phrases in a
manner more typical of chamber music
than rock. More remarkable yet is
Gallucci's ability to weave melodies
and riffs together without ever
resorting to mere rhetoric.
"Friendly Birds" finally soars into
the distance after a series of
shattering climaxes all the more
impressive for the fact that no
drums are involved. "Down at Circes'
Place" is, in its way, equally
extraordinary, effectively fusing a
link between the psychedelia of the
late '60s and the more expansive
styles to come. Its climactic two
minutes, best likened to the sound
of Santana on a really bad trip, has
to be one of the most satisfyingly
cacophonous noises in all of rock,
despite the total absence of
electric guitars. The album also
contains two epic tracks in "The
Spiritual Death of Howard Greer" and
"Seventy Five," only one of which
really comes off. But while the
former drinks deep from the well of
hippie pretension, with its tale of
some straight who's, like,
spiritually dead but doesn't know it
— and throws in everything from
Gregorian chant to good-time boogie
— the latter is a genuine tour de
force. Here it's not just Gallucci's
organ playing that shines. Vocalist
Jeff Hawks gets to demonstrate a
truly formidable vocal technique —
one moment up close and breathy, the
next shrieking up a storm — while
guitarist Joey Newman also turns in
a genuinely thrilling solo,
featuring a curiously harsh, lo-fi
tone that was entirely his own to
round off the album. Both CD
reissues feature extra tracks that
never come close to matching the
original album, but the Eclectic
version benefits from vastly
improved sound quality.
2005
: Opeth - Ghost Reveries:
Stockholm's most unpredictable
metallic sons Opeth have offered
another step on their dark journey
into the Maelstrom that combines
progressive sonics, and acoustic and
electric instrumentation, all the
while extrapolating on their
now-trademark brand of death metal.
Stepping aside from the malevolent
acoustic elegance of 2003's
Damnation without abandoning the
textural advances, Ghost Reveries is
a tour de force of creativity,
power, and innovation. Alternately
melodic and brutal, the album takes
the band's progressive acumen to a
new level while never abandoning the
crunch. Vocalist, guitarist, and
lyricist Mikael Åkerfeldt has become
a complete poet of the dark side.
With bandmates Per Wiberg on
keyboards, drummer Martin Lopez,
guitarist Peter Lindgren, and
bassist Martin Mendez, Åkerfeldt has
forged ahead into a vein of this
music that moves it further forward
while embracing not only elements of
the band's foundational past, but
also elements from the annals of
heavy metal. The sheer, harsh,
tragic beauty of Ghost Reveries
reveals it as more a hunted album
than a haunted one. The opener
"Ghost of Perdition" is layered with
heartbreakingly lyrical beauty —
amidst its crack and burn — with
vocals either sung poetically or
growled from the depths of the
ravages of the human throat: "In
time the hissing of her sanity/Faded
out her voice and soiled her
name/And like marked pages in a
diary/Everything seemed that is
unstained/The incoherent talk of
ordinary days/Why would we really
need to live/Decide what is clear
and what's within a haze/What you
should take and what to give...."
The guitars, electric and acoustic,
intertwining and winding around one
another with quick figures, move the
melody into the labyrinthine
"Reverie/Harlequin Forest," that
goes on for over 11 minutes while
its tales of sickness and tenderness
rub against one another and become
one tortured being. Justification
and easy moral judgments become
futile, reflections of painful
memory and dislocation are taut,
walking a rusty razor wire as
propulsive drums and crackling
guitars carry the singer into his
desolation. Ultimately, Ghost
Reveries comes together like a
suite, characters have various faces
and traits, but they are all
reflections in a mirror that retains
no permanent image. This album is a
culmination of everything Opeth have
worked toward throughout their
career. It's fully realized,
stunningly beautiful, and
emotionally fragmented; it's a
terrain where power, tenderness, and
sheer grief hold forth under heavy
manners. Awesome.
2006
- Muse - Black Holes and
Revelations: Naysayers listen
up. Teignmouth, England's Muse
refuse to be your "next" Radiohead.
Since forming in 1997, this
alternative rock trio has
continuously battled comparisons to
the famed Oxford group while
ambitiously creating a sound of
their own. U.K. fans have praised
the group since the albums "Sunburn"
and "Hyper Music" despite it taking
Americans until Absolution to
discover Muse and give them their
props. Whether or not you championed
the grand dramatics of Absolution,
Muse is a solid band and Black Holes
and Revelations defines that with a
passion. Rich Costey joins Muse in
the co-production of this 11-song
set; together they've created the
band's most realized and meticulous
album to date. "Take A Bow" sets the
scene immediately; a mesmerizing,
full orchestrated rock sound,
layered in waves of synthesizers and
percussion, build up to
vocalist/guitarist Matthew Bellamy's
aching performance of a world torn
apart by it's own instability.
Frequently compared to Queen's
Freddie Mercury and Thom Yorke,
Bellamy has totally come into his
own here. He, drummer Dominic Howard
and bassist Chris Wolstenholme
appear completely in sync for the
first time, really. Sure, their
previous work has shown promise, but
they sound like a complete band on
Black Holes and Revelations. Songs
such as the sultry swagger of
"Supermassive Black Hole" and the
razor-edged paranoia of "Assassin"
are good examples of how adamant
Muse is in delivering the biggest
rock & roll package they possibly
can. Bellamy howls "You and I must
fight for our rights/You and I must
fight to survive" on the riotous
Rush-like megalomania of "Knights of
Cydonia," They've totally fought for
their craft with this one. It might
have taken four albums for Americans
to get it, but with Black Holes and
Revelations, the whole world should
be watching.